Elon Musk's X is in a legal battle with the Indian government over content moderation

來源 Cryptopolitan

X, Elon Musk’s social media platform, has crossed legal paths with the Indian government in the Karnataka High Court, alleging unlawful content regulation and censorship against arms of Narendra Modi’s administration.

K.G. Raghavan, the lawyer representing X in India, heads into a legal clash with the government over content moderation, as the matter has now been escalated to the courts for resolution.

Elon Musk wages war against social media censorship in India 

The problem, X claims, is that the Indian government’s IT ministry has expanded its censorship powers with the Sahyog portal, which was launched by the Ministry of Home Affairs in 2024. 

The government-run website has been tagged a “censorship portal” by X as it gives every government official the authority to issue content takedown orders. 

On the other hand, the Indian government denies this and has said the portal only notifies companies of their due diligence obligations. 

The social media platform has been in conflict with Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government due to content removal requests for quite some time, and the website X is complaining about makes it worse. 

“This is the danger, My Lord, that is done now, if every Tom, Dick, and Harry officer is authorised,” K. G. Raghavan, X’s lawyer said at the hearing immediately drawing condemnation from India’s Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, who was quick to correct that “officers are not Tom, Dick, or Harry … they are statutory functionaries.”

“No social media intermediary can expect completely unregulated functioning,” Mehta eventually said, hinting at more future clashes between X and his country’s government. 

X raised concerns over the interpretation of the Information Technology (IT) Act months ago

The lawsuit which coincides with Musk’s efforts to expand his ventures, Starlink and Tesla, in India, comes months X raised concerns over the interpretation of the Information Technology (IT) Act, particularly its use of Section 79(3)(b), which it argued violates Supreme Court rulings and hampers freedom of expression.

X alleged that the government is using the section to create a parallel content blocking mechanism, bypassing the structured legal process outlined in Section 69A and contradicting the Supreme Court’s 2015 ruling in the Shreya Singhal case. 

That ruling states that content can only be blocked through a proper judicial process or the legally defined route under Section 69A. However, there is also Section 79(3)(b), which mandates online platforms to remove illegal content when directed by either a court order or a government notification, which can now come from the Sahyog portal. 

Should a platform fail to comply within 36 hours, it could lose its safe harbor protection under Section 79(1) and be held accountable under various laws, including the Indian Penal Code (IPC).

X contested the interpretation by claiming the provision does not grant the government independent authority to block content. The Elon Musk-led social media platform accused Indian authorities of exploiting the law to impose arbitrary censorship without following due process.

Despite X’s assertions, the government maintains that the Sahyog portal is not a censorship tool and has pointed out that major platforms like Google and YouTube are fine with it. 

The latest hearing in the case has shown that a resolution has not been reached, and neither party seems willing to back down. 

If the hearing goes in X’s favor, it could limit the ability of the government to demand the takedown of alleged offending content without judicial oversight and encourage other platforms to rebel. However, commentators suspect the Indian government will defend its regulatory authority ferociously, which means this case may not end anytime soon.

Cryptopolitan Academy: Want to grow your money in 2025? Learn how to do it with DeFi in our upcoming webclass. Save Your Spot

免責聲明:僅供參考。 過去的表現並不預示未來的結果。
placeholder
AI再掀高潮!Meta股價狂飆,緊隨輝達創下歷史新高TradingKey - Meta宣佈重組AI部門,提振其股價盤中跳漲,創下新的記錄。當地時間週一(6月30日),Meta (META)股價盤中跳漲至747.9美元,創下歷史新高。截止收盤,該股收漲0.61%,報738.09美元。(哪些機構持有Meta股票,可查看「明星投資者」)【Meta股價走勢圖,來源:TradingView】Meta股價上漲主要是受該公司的人工智慧業務推動。Meta Plat
作者  TradingKey
昨日 05: 58
TradingKey - Meta宣佈重組AI部門,提振其股價盤中跳漲,創下新的記錄。當地時間週一(6月30日),Meta (META)股價盤中跳漲至747.9美元,創下歷史新高。截止收盤,該股收漲0.61%,報738.09美元。(哪些機構持有Meta股票,可查看「明星投資者」)【Meta股價走勢圖,來源:TradingView】Meta股價上漲主要是受該公司的人工智慧業務推動。Meta Plat
placeholder
日幣2025年上半年漲9%!7月繼續升值?分析師這樣說2025年上半年,美元/日圓(USD/JPY)累計下跌9%,創下近年來最佳表現。
作者  Alison Ho
23 小時前
2025年上半年,美元/日圓(USD/JPY)累計下跌9%,創下近年來最佳表現。
placeholder
比特幣價格預測:BTC跌破107,000美元,即使交易所儲備降至6年低點比特幣(BTC)在週二撰寫時跌破107,000美元,繼續從前一天的小幅回調。儘管出現下跌,但企業需求依然看漲,像Strategy、區塊鏈集團和Metaplanet等公司正在增加其財政儲備中的比特幣持有量
作者  FXStreet
21 小時前
比特幣(BTC)在週二撰寫時跌破107,000美元,繼續從前一天的小幅回調。儘管出現下跌,但企業需求依然看漲,像Strategy、區塊鏈集團和Metaplanet等公司正在增加其財政儲備中的比特幣持有量
placeholder
逢七必漲!美股會打破「7月上漲魔咒」嗎?7月是美股表現最強的月份之一,標普500平均報酬率為3.35%。
作者  Alison Ho
20 小時前
7月是美股表現最強的月份之一,標普500平均報酬率為3.35%。
placeholder
歐元兌美元平價敘事被擊潰,歐元匯率料創二十年來最長連漲!TradingKey - 2025年上半年,美元以半個世紀以來的最快速度貶值,歐元兌美元匯率(EUR/USD)也強勁反彈,並將錄得罕見的9日連漲,這讓華爾街對今年歐元匯率的預測報告成為廢紙。截至撰稿(7月1日),歐元兌美元匯率日內上漲0.15%,報1.18042,為2021年9月以來的近四年最高。2025年迄今,歐元匯率已經飆升14%,同期美元指數(DXY)下跌約11%,創上世紀70年代以來最差上
作者  TradingKey
4 小時前
TradingKey - 2025年上半年,美元以半個世紀以來的最快速度貶值,歐元兌美元匯率(EUR/USD)也強勁反彈,並將錄得罕見的9日連漲,這讓華爾街對今年歐元匯率的預測報告成為廢紙。截至撰稿(7月1日),歐元兌美元匯率日內上漲0.15%,報1.18042,為2021年9月以來的近四年最高。2025年迄今,歐元匯率已經飆升14%,同期美元指數(DXY)下跌約11%,創上世紀70年代以來最差上
goTop
quote