Analysts now expect Wall Street’s S&P 500 to tumble as low as 3,700 this year

Mitrade
coverImg
Source: DepositPhotos

Wall Street analysts are now warning that the S&P 500 could sink to 3,700 this year, even without a full-blown recession. That’s what Chris Senyek, chief investment strategist at Wolfe Research, told clients on Thursday.


He said the index could drop anywhere between 3,700 and 4,100 if the U.S. economy slows down, making it a 37% to 30% crash from where it started in January.


The S&P 500 has already dropped more than 7% this year and is sitting 11% lower than its peak in February. It officially entered a bear market earlier this month after President Donald Trump dropped his April 2 tariff bomb. Since then, the market has been moving sideways.


Earnings expectations collapse under recession fears


Chris said the biggest danger right now is what happens if the U.S. slides into a recession. If that happens, he expects S&P 500 earnings per share (EPS) to fall from $266 to $225, which would be a 15% drop. That drop lines up with what has happened in past downturns.


“If uncertainty caused by tariff policy were to push the U.S. economy into recession in 2025, we’d expect SPX EPS to fall at least 15% from current levels in line with the median EPS peak to trough over the past four recessions, of 16.7%,” Chris wrote Thursday.


He also pointed out that price-to-earnings ratios would shrink in that case. The S&P 500 currently trades at 19.4x earnings. If it drops to the 15-year average of 16.6x or the 10-year average of 18.4x, and EPS hits $225, then the index would crash to somewhere between 3,700 and 4,100.


For now, earnings season is off to a solid start. Out of the 157 companies on the S&P 500 that have reported so far, 76% beat expectations. That’s better than what analysts were expecting on March 31.


Back then, they predicted a 7.2% growth rate, but the current blended rate—which combines actual results and remaining forecasts—is now at 8%, according to John Butters, senior earnings analyst at FactSet.


Death cross formation warns of more losses ahead


The charts are flashing warnings too. On April 14, the S&P 500’s 50-day moving average dropped under its 200-day moving average, forming what traders call a death cross.


This kind of crossover isn’t normal. It’s only happened 50 times since 1928, and when it does, things usually get worse before they get better.


The data was tracked by Bank of America, and it shows that in the 20 days after a death cross forms, the S&P 500 has fallen 0.5% on average, and it’s ended lower more than half of those times.


If you stretch that window to 40 days, things don’t look much better. The index still ends up lower in almost half the cases, but when it rises, it gains 0.9% on average.


Push out to 80 days, though, and there’s some light. The index rises more often than not and brings in an average gain of 2.6% from when the cross forms.


But in this case, things are even messier. The 200-day moving average was also dropping when the death cross hit, which makes the pattern more dangerous.


Bank of America pulled data from times when both moving averages were trending down during the five days before the crossover. In those rare setups, the S&P 500 was down two out of every three times in the following 20 days, with an average loss of 1.6%.


The good news doesn’t really start until day 40, when the index rises in more than half of those cases and gains around 1%. If you wait two months, the odds are even better—67% of the time, the market goes up, and the average return grows to 3.5%.


Still, those gains only come after traders get knocked around. Bank of America’s Paul Ciana told clients this week, “This suggests we should consider buying a dip/retest of lows in April.”


As of now, resistance for the S&P 500 sits around 5,500, and the index hasn’t been able to push past that level and was last seen just under it, trading at 5,483.



Read more

  • Bitcoin Plunges 13% in a Week as Market Retreats to $60,000 Level
  • Silver Price Forecast: XAG/USD hits yearly lows below $47.50 amid hawkish Fed sentiment
  • * The content presented above, whether from a third party or not, is considered as general advice only.  This article should not be construed as containing investment advice, investment recommendations, an offer of or solicitation for any transactions in financial instruments.

    goTop
    quote
    Related Articles
    placeholder
    Weekly Report: The AI capex consensus was wrong last week — the scorecard points to one crowding riskThree consensus calls went into last week. Two were wrong: the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index fell 12.15% and Micron dropped 17.46% after beating estimates, while the Dow lost only 0.94%. The scorecard says the mistake was not about AI demand but about how crowded the trade had become — and CoreWeave, Cisco and Applied Materials will grade it again this week.
    Author  Irene Q.
    Nov 09, Mon
    Three consensus calls went into last week. Two were wrong: the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index fell 12.15% and Micron dropped 17.46% after beating estimates, while the Dow lost only 0.94%. The scorecard says the mistake was not about AI demand but about how crowded the trade had become — and CoreWeave, Cisco and Applied Materials will grade it again this week.
    placeholder
    The Dow's 1,569-point day was a rotation, not a breakoutThe Dow jumped 1,569.40 points (+3.03%) to 53,356.12 — its best post-midterm session in 44 years — while the Nasdaq Composite added just 1.44%. Equal-weight S&P versus the Nasdaq 100 had already gapped 14 points before the vote, a 99th-percentile divergence. The index is still 2.54% below its August high.
    Author  Irene Q.
    Nov 05, Thu
    The Dow jumped 1,569.40 points (+3.03%) to 53,356.12 — its best post-midterm session in 44 years — while the Nasdaq Composite added just 1.44%. Equal-weight S&P versus the Nasdaq 100 had already gapped 14 points before the vote, a 99th-percentile divergence. The index is still 2.54% below its August high.
    placeholder
    US GDP grew 3.4% and core PCE held at 3.1% — December is now a hike trade, not a cut tradeUS Q3 GDP rose 3.4%, above the 3.1% estimate, while September headline PCE hit 3.6% and core held at 3.1%. December hike odds are near 90%; inventories, AI capex and energy explain why.
    Author  Irene Q.
    Oct 30, Fri
    US Q3 GDP rose 3.4%, above the 3.1% estimate, while September headline PCE hit 3.6% and core held at 3.1%. December hike odds are near 90%; inventories, AI capex and energy explain why.
    placeholder
    US September CPI recap: inflation hits 3.7% as core runs hot — is an October Fed hike back on the table?September CPI landed hot: headline 3.7% y/y, core 2.6% y/y and 0.3% m/m. October hike odds jumped from ~22% to ~37% — yet the dollar faded to 101.74, gold closed higher and the S&P 500 fell 1.11%. Here is the full repricing, the levels and what to watch next.
    Author  Irene Q.
    Oct 15, Thu
    September CPI landed hot: headline 3.7% y/y, core 2.6% y/y and 0.3% m/m. October hike odds jumped from ~22% to ~37% — yet the dollar faded to 101.74, gold closed higher and the S&P 500 fell 1.11%. Here is the full repricing, the levels and what to watch next.
    placeholder
    Strong profits, falling shares: bank earnings day one meets a memory-chip rout — with CPI and ASML aheadGoldman Sachs blew past estimates (EPS $17.01 vs $13.09 expected, profit +33%) while JPMorgan missed ($5.75 vs $5.93) and Wells Fargo fell 3% — yet the S&P 500 finished flat at 7,805.45, pinned below its record close as a memory-chip rout (SOX −2.67%, Micron under $1,000) kept the pressure on. Tonight brings the week's decider: US September CPI at 8:30 ET, then Bank of America, Morgan Stanley, BlackRock and ASML before the open. Here are the levels, both cases, and the watch list.
    Author  Irene Q.
    Oct 14, Wed
    Goldman Sachs blew past estimates (EPS $17.01 vs $13.09 expected, profit +33%) while JPMorgan missed ($5.75 vs $5.93) and Wells Fargo fell 3% — yet the S&P 500 finished flat at 7,805.45, pinned below its record close as a memory-chip rout (SOX −2.67%, Micron under $1,000) kept the pressure on. Tonight brings the week's decider: US September CPI at 8:30 ET, then Bank of America, Morgan Stanley, BlackRock and ASML before the open. Here are the levels, both cases, and the watch list.
    Live Quotes
    Name / SymbolChart% Change / Price
    US500
    US500
    0.00%0.00

    S&P 500 Related Articles

    • Wall Street’s Top 10 US Stocks for 2026 vs What Reddit Is Actually Buying
    • Top 10 Best Brokers for Indices Trading
    • S&P 500 to 7,500 in 2026? How Tech Stocks Could Drive 20% Gains (Or Not)
    • How To Trade Indices? Index Trading Beginner's Guide for 2023

    Click to view more