If Stocks Tumble, History Says Investors Who Own This 1 Type of Stock Lose About Half as Much as Those Who Don’t.

Source The Motley Fool

Key Points

  • Since 1973, dividend payers have fallen by 14.4%, versus 28.2% for non-payers, during S&P 500 drawdowns of 10% or more.

  • Dividend growers returned 10.2% a year with less volatility than the average stock, while cutters lost 1% a year with the most volatility.

  • Favor dividend growth over the biggest yield for the best results.

  • 10 stocks we like better than S&P 500 Index ›

The S&P 500 (SNPINDEX:^GSPC) fell 4.4% on Nov. 5, its worst day since April 2025. It was another reminder of how quickly stocks can tumble.

However, when stocks fall, not all tumble as much. Research from Hartford Funds, using Ned Davis Research data, shows that since 1973 the stocks that held up better in big declines have been dividend payers. In market drawdowns of 10% or more, dividend-paying stocks fell 14.4%, versus 28.2% for non-dividend-paying stocks. That's about half as much.

Missed Nvidia in 2009? This Rare Signal Is Flashing Again. In 2009, a "Double Down" signal flashed for a little-known chipmaker called Nvidia. For the first time in years, that same "Total Conviction" signal is flashing for a company 1/100th the size of Nvidia. Continue »

Here is what to look for in a dividend stock to help cushion the blow of a future stock market slump.

Man reviewing financial charts on a laptop and printed reports at a home office desk.

Image source: Getty Images.

What the data shows

Hartford Fund's analysis covers every S&P 500 drawdown of 10% or more from 1973 through 2025. In those periods, dividend-paying stocks fell an average of 14.4%. The equal-weighted S&P 500, a good proxy for the average stock, fell 19%. Meanwhile, stocks that didn't pay dividends tumbled 28.2%.

In other words, dividend payers lost about half as much as non-payers during a stock market correction. While they still lost money, they helped preserve more wealth during a market downdraft.

Why dividend payers hold up better

Hartford suggested two reasons why dividend stocks tend to hold up much better than non-payers during a market downturn. Many dividend stocks tend to be concentrated in industries less sensitive to the economic cycle. For example, most consumer staples and utility stocks pay dividends because companies in these industries generate stable cash flow due to resilient demand.

Additionally, a company typically needs to have a track record of profitability and relatively predictable cash flow before it initiates a dividend. That business maturity would also make a company's stock price less volatile.

One type of dividend stock stands out

While dividend payers have historically delivered higher total returns with less volatility than non-payers, one group of dividend stocks stood out from the pack:

Bar chart: S&P 500 dividend growers returned 10.22% annually in 1973–2025, while dividend cutters lost 0.96%.

Image source: The author.

Companies that grew their dividends outperformed the average dividend stock and had lower volatility. Companies that cut or eliminated theirs lost money on average, with the most volatility of any group.

Hartford also found that the highest yields haven't been the best bet. Since 1930, stocks with the highest payout ratios (which typically have the highest yields) outperformed the market about half the time, similar to companies with much lower payout ratios. However, the sweet spot was companies with an average dividend payout ratio of 49%. These companies prioritized dividend payments while maintaining plenty of flexibility to continue growing their dividends even during more challenging times.

3 ways to use this data

Those results point to a few simple ways to put the data to work before the next pullback.

  1. Favor dividend growth over the biggest yield. A rising payout signals confidence, while a very high yield can signal trouble.
  2. Check the payout ratio. A high payout ratio leaves little room for growth if profits drop.
  3. Treat dividends as a cushion, not a shield. Even dividend payers lost money on average in these drawdowns.

The risk

While dividend stocks have historically helped cushion the blow during downturns, that doesn't guarantee they will outperform during the next one. For example, S&P 500 Dividend Aristocrats® (the term Dividend Aristocrats® is a registered trademark of Standard & Poor's Financial Services LLC) -- S&P 500 members with 25 or more years of annual dividend increases -- outperformed the market during the dot-com crash and global financial crisis. However, they underperformed during the COVID crash.

Further, weaker companies tend to cut their dividends during periods of market stress. As we saw before, dividend cutters and eliminators have historically delivered negative total returns. That's why it's important to check a company's dividend payout ratio to ensure it has plenty of cushion to weather a market downturn.

Focus on dividend growth, not yield

When stocks tumble, history shows dividend payers tend to fall about half as far as stocks that don't pay dividends, and dividend growers have done even better over time. It's a cushion, not a guarantee. If you're worried about a potential pullback, lean toward investing in companies with growing, well-covered dividends rather than non-payers and those with the highest yields.

Should you buy stock in S&P 500 Index right now?

Before you buy stock in S&P 500 Index, consider this:

The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy now… and S&P 500 Index wasn’t one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years.

Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $321,850!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $955,232!*

Now, it’s worth noting Stock Advisor’s total average return is 793% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 203% for the S&P 500. Don't miss the latest top 10 list, available with Stock Advisor, and join an investing community built by individual investors for individual investors.

See the 10 stocks »

*Stock Advisor returns as of November 18, 2026.

Matt DiLallo has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends S&P Global. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Disclaimer: For information purposes only. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
placeholder
Anthropic is six times oversubscribed at $1.4 trillion while Nvidia is down 32% — the AI trade has two pricesAnthropic lists on Nasdaq as ANT on Thursday at $70 ~ $78 a share, raising up to $64.4 billion at a target valuation near $1.4 trillion, and the book is reportedly six times covered. In the same six weeks, Nvidia has fallen 32% and the QQQ is 10.9% below its October peak. Private capital and public markets are marking the same AI complex at two very different prices. This piece separates the two books: what the S-1 shows, who is anchoring the $26 billion private placement, and what Thursday's debut would have to do to change the public tape.
Author  Irene Q.
Nov 16, Mon
Anthropic lists on Nasdaq as ANT on Thursday at $70 ~ $78 a share, raising up to $64.4 billion at a target valuation near $1.4 trillion, and the book is reportedly six times covered. In the same six weeks, Nvidia has fallen 32% and the QQQ is 10.9% below its October peak. Private capital and public markets are marking the same AI complex at two very different prices. This piece separates the two books: what the S-1 shows, who is anchoring the $26 billion private placement, and what Thursday's debut would have to do to change the public tape.
placeholder
Gold Price Analysis Today | Forex Gold Analysis | XAU/USD Analysis - November 16, 2026Get the latest gold price analysis, forex gold insights, and XAU/USD analysis for November 16, 2026. Read on for the details.
Author  Mitrade
Nov 16, Mon
Get the latest gold price analysis, forex gold insights, and XAU/USD analysis for November 16, 2026. Read on for the details.
placeholder
Weekly Report: DXY 103.41, 10-year 5.15%, AUD carry 3bp — three FX regimes flipped in one weekThe dollar index rose 1.09% to 103.41, a 19-month high, while the US 10-year closed at 5.154% and the Australia-US two-year spread collapsed to about 3 basis points from 36. EURUSD fell 1.59% to 1.1024, USDJPY rose 1.51% to 159.78 and AUDUSD fell 1.79% to 0.6764, a 10-month low. Three FX regimes — the broad dollar, the US rate level and the Australian carry premium — flipped in the same week. This report marks the thresholds, ranks which one can flip back first, and lists the week's calendar.
Author  Irene Q.
Nov 16, Mon
The dollar index rose 1.09% to 103.41, a 19-month high, while the US 10-year closed at 5.154% and the Australia-US two-year spread collapsed to about 3 basis points from 36. EURUSD fell 1.59% to 1.1024, USDJPY rose 1.51% to 159.78 and AUDUSD fell 1.79% to 0.6764, a 10-month low. Three FX regimes — the broad dollar, the US rate level and the Australian carry premium — flipped in the same week. This report marks the thresholds, ranks which one can flip back first, and lists the week's calendar.
placeholder
Gold Price Analysis Today | Forex Gold Analysis | XAU/USD Analysis - November 17, 2026Get the latest gold price analysis, forex gold insights, and XAU/USD analysis for November 17, 2026. Read on for the details.
Author  Mitrade
Yesterday 05: 40
Get the latest gold price analysis, forex gold insights, and XAU/USD analysis for November 17, 2026. Read on for the details.
placeholder
Gold Price Analysis Today | Forex Gold Analysis | XAU/USD Analysis - November 18, 2026Get the latest gold price analysis, forex gold insights, and XAU/USD analysis for November 18, 2026. Read on for the details.
Author  Mitrade
11 hours ago
Get the latest gold price analysis, forex gold insights, and XAU/USD analysis for November 18, 2026. Read on for the details.
goTop
quote