The S&P 500 Looks Cheaper Than It Has in Over 3 Years, but There’s a Catch

Source The Motley Fool

Key Points

  • The S&P 500's forward P/E reached its lowest level since November 2023 this month.

  • Corporate earnings have trounced expectations so far this year, pushing analysts' expectations higher.

  • At the current valuation, there's room for error in analysts' optimistic forecasts.

  • Motley Fool Issues Rare "Total Conviction" Buy Alert ›

Despite some bumps in the road, the last three years have been fantastic for stock investors. The S&P 500 (SNPINDEX:^GSPC) index is up about 80% since the start of November 2023, fueled by the big tech stocks at the forefront of the artificial intelligence (AI) industry. Despite the surge in stock prices, the index looks just as cheap by one measure as it was over three years ago.

The S&P 500 saw its forward P/E ratio fall to 17.7 in the postmidterm rout on Nov. 5. That now sits well below the five- and 10-year average forward P/E ratios for the index (19.8 and 19.1, respectively), and it's the lowest level the metric has reached since Nov. 1, 2023, according to data and analytics company FactSet.

Missed AI’s "Act 1"? Act 2 Could Be 15x Bigger. Most investors think they missed the AI boat because they didn't buy Nvidia in 2005. But according to our analysts, we’re only at the end of "Act 1"—the R&D phase. "Act 2" is the global rollout. Continue »

Stocks have recovered a bit from the recent sell-off, and their valuations remain relatively attractive compared to where they've traded in recent years. Before investors expect another 80% climb in stock prices over the next three years, though, there's a big catch they should be aware of.

Concerned stock traders react to falling market data on screens as a businessman considers his next move.

Image source: Getty Images.

Rising stock prices and declining valuations

The forward P/E is a measure made with imperfect information. While we can know the price of stocks (P) with 100% certainty, the earnings (E) half of the equation is based on analysts' best guesses. When those guesses change as we gain new information, the P/E ratio can change significantly. For example, the S&P 500's forward P/E ratio fell from a relatively high 22 at the start of the year to less than 18 today, even as the index climbed.

2026 earnings came in well above expectations at the start of the year, prompting analysts to raise their outlooks for future earnings growth. Actual earnings between the third quarter of last year and the second quarter of this year exceeded analyst expectations by an average of 13.8%. For the third quarter, companies have reported earnings about 2.7% above estimates, which is less than the usual earnings surprise. But analysts already have high expectations of about 30% earnings growth.

Those high expectations carry into the fourth quarter, when analysts expect 28.4% earnings growth, and slow down slightly in the first quarter of next year to 19.5%. Second-quarter forecasts fell to just 3% earnings growth, as some big companies face tough comparables due to one-time investment gains in 2026, but analysts expect 16.1% full-year earnings growth for the S&P 500 in 2027.

Analysts have raised their growth expectations considerably from the start of the year, pushing the forward P/E ratio lower. The big catch, of course, is that future earnings expectations are far from knowable. Even after the stellar earnings results of the last few quarters, the S&P 500's trailing P/E (using actual financial results) of around 25 remains above the five- and 10-year averages (24.4 and 23.7, respectively).

Will earnings keep climbing?

While it's impossible to know if earnings growth can match the torrid pace analysts currently expect, stock investors earn higher returns over the long run because they're willing to accept that risk.

Some argue that analysts' earnings expectations still underappreciate the massive growth opportunity for artificial intelligence. With big tech companies piling growing amounts of cash into their data center build-outs, further revenue growth acceleration could be on the horizon as income-producing assets come online.

On the other side of the coin, some see significant hurdles for further growth among the AI stocks, with capital markets getting tighter and increased pressure from regulators. That could slow down the build-out and bring revenue growth to a halt.

While big AI stocks have the biggest impact on the S&P 500's overall earnings expectations, there are hundreds of companies that are mostly unaffected by the artificial intelligence build-out. Investors willing to dig into individual stocks and their earnings outlooks could find underappreciated opportunities as everyone focuses on AI.

Most importantly, with stock prices relatively low compared to earnings expectations, there's room for error. Stocks still look attractive after an 80% climb since they were last valued this low, but it's important to note that earnings growth expectations are higher now than they were three years ago. That leaves more room to disappoint.

Should you buy stock in S&P 500 Index right now?

Before you buy stock in S&P 500 Index, consider this:

The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy now… and S&P 500 Index wasn’t one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years.

Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $335,171!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $1,000,640!*

Now, it’s worth noting Stock Advisor’s total average return is 823% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 208% for the S&P 500. Don't miss the latest top 10 list, available with Stock Advisor, and join an investing community built by individual investors for individual investors.

See the 10 stocks »

*Stock Advisor returns as of November 16, 2026.

Adam Levy has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Disclaimer: For information purposes only. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
placeholder
Nvidia slid 7.7% after hours while AMD and Broadcom rose — the AI trade changed hands, it didn't breakNvidia closed Wednesday at 173.73, up 2.87%, then fell as much as 8.1% to 159.44 after reports that its board was preparing for a possible leadership change. The same session, the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index rose 5.7% with all 30 components higher, CoreWeave jumped 24.7% on 168% revenue growth, and Micron added 11.9%. If AI demand were being repriced, AMD and Broadcom would not be bid. This is a governance discount on one name, and 204.54 — the 200-day average — is the level that settles it.
Author  Irene Q.
Nov 12, Thu
Nvidia closed Wednesday at 173.73, up 2.87%, then fell as much as 8.1% to 159.44 after reports that its board was preparing for a possible leadership change. The same session, the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index rose 5.7% with all 30 components higher, CoreWeave jumped 24.7% on 168% revenue growth, and Micron added 11.9%. If AI demand were being repriced, AMD and Broadcom would not be bid. This is a governance discount on one name, and 204.54 — the 200-day average — is the level that settles it.
placeholder
Gold hit a one-year low while central banks bought 321 tonnes — the sellers were never the ones you thinkSpot gold closed at 3,876 on Thursday, down 2.8% and its lowest close in more than a year, with an intraday low near 3,852. The dollar is at a 19-month high of 103.21 and the 10-year yield is at 5.10%, so the price move is easy to explain. What is harder to explain is who sold: central banks bought 321 tonnes in Q3, the PBoC added for a 24th straight month, ETF holdings are near a record 4,256 tonnes, and roughly 95% of the futures selling came from non-reportable and sovereign-type accounts rather than hedge funds. This piece separates the two books that have to balance.
Author  Irene Q.
Nov 13, Fri
Spot gold closed at 3,876 on Thursday, down 2.8% and its lowest close in more than a year, with an intraday low near 3,852. The dollar is at a 19-month high of 103.21 and the 10-year yield is at 5.10%, so the price move is easy to explain. What is harder to explain is who sold: central banks bought 321 tonnes in Q3, the PBoC added for a 24th straight month, ETF holdings are near a record 4,256 tonnes, and roughly 95% of the futures selling came from non-reportable and sovereign-type accounts rather than hedge funds. This piece separates the two books that have to balance.
placeholder
Brent rose 3.3% and US crude stocks built 4.66 million barrels in the same weekBrent January settled at 95.82, up 3.3%, and WTI at 88.74, up 2.55%, after the US signalled it would not pursue a deal with Iran and attacks on Gulf shipping continued. In the same week, EIA data showed US crude inventories rising 4.657 million barrels against expectations of a 1.1 million draw, with gasoline up another 1.799 million. OPEC output also rebounded 1.96 million barrels a day to 27.16 million in October, led by Saudi Arabia at 10.56 million. This piece separates the geopolitical premium from the physical balance and lays out where each side of the trade is anchored.
Author  Irene Q.
Nov 13, Fri
Brent January settled at 95.82, up 3.3%, and WTI at 88.74, up 2.55%, after the US signalled it would not pursue a deal with Iran and attacks on Gulf shipping continued. In the same week, EIA data showed US crude inventories rising 4.657 million barrels against expectations of a 1.1 million draw, with gasoline up another 1.799 million. OPEC output also rebounded 1.96 million barrels a day to 27.16 million in October, led by Saudi Arabia at 10.56 million. This piece separates the geopolitical premium from the physical balance and lays out where each side of the trade is anchored.
placeholder
Anthropic is six times oversubscribed at $1.4 trillion while Nvidia is down 32% — the AI trade has two pricesAnthropic lists on Nasdaq as ANT on Thursday at $70 ~ $78 a share, raising up to $64.4 billion at a target valuation near $1.4 trillion, and the book is reportedly six times covered. In the same six weeks, Nvidia has fallen 32% and the QQQ is 10.9% below its October peak. Private capital and public markets are marking the same AI complex at two very different prices. This piece separates the two books: what the S-1 shows, who is anchoring the $26 billion private placement, and what Thursday's debut would have to do to change the public tape.
Author  Irene Q.
5 hours ago
Anthropic lists on Nasdaq as ANT on Thursday at $70 ~ $78 a share, raising up to $64.4 billion at a target valuation near $1.4 trillion, and the book is reportedly six times covered. In the same six weeks, Nvidia has fallen 32% and the QQQ is 10.9% below its October peak. Private capital and public markets are marking the same AI complex at two very different prices. This piece separates the two books: what the S-1 shows, who is anchoring the $26 billion private placement, and what Thursday's debut would have to do to change the public tape.
placeholder
Gold Price Analysis Today | Forex Gold Analysis | XAU/USD Analysis - November 16, 2026Get the latest gold price analysis, forex gold insights, and XAU/USD analysis for November 16, 2026. Read on for the details.
Author  Mitrade
5 hours ago
Get the latest gold price analysis, forex gold insights, and XAU/USD analysis for November 16, 2026. Read on for the details.
goTop
quote