Michael Burry Cashed In Caterpillar Puts After a Nearly 4x Gain Even as CAT Stock Fell 10% in Its Worst Week in 18 Months. Is Caterpillar Still Overvalued, or Did Burry Just Lock In the Easy Money?

Source The Motley Fool

Key Points

  • Caterpillar's shares were booming because of AI-driven demand for construction equipment.

  • The stock is now down by close to 50% due to fears of an AI slowdown.

  • Investors like Michael Burry have made money betting against Caterpillar, but he recently took off his position.

  • These 10 stocks could mint the next wave of millionaires ›

Caterpillar (NYSE:CAT) has quickly fallen 44% from its highs, which is the largest drawdown for the construction equipment company in the last 10 years. The stock was riding high because of the company's importance to the artificial intelligence (AI) infrastructure build-out but has since fallen along with many other thematic stocks.

Famous investor and short seller Michael Burry publicly bet against Caterpillar using put options, and his position increased by about 4x in less than a year. He has since closed most of his position, which he wrote about in his newsletter this week.

Missed Nvidia in 2009? This Rare Signal Is Flashing Again. In 2009, a "Double Down" signal flashed for a little-known chipmaker called Nvidia. For the first time in years, that same "Total Conviction" signal is flashing for a company 1/100th the size of Nvidia. Continue »

Does that mean now could finally be a good time to buy the dip on Caterpillar, or is Burry just getting out while the easy money has been made?

Construction demand boom

Spending on construction has grown due to the need for data centers, computer chip factories, and other industrial sites in the United States that are fueling the AI boom.

Caterpillar directly services the construction of these sites with its myriad vehicles and equipment, such as bulldozers. It has many other business lines related to construction, such as equipment rental, financing, and turbines. It is the go-to brand for building things.

Last quarter, revenue for power and energy grew 18% year over year, driven by the AI boom. However, its other large segment, basic construction services, grew 18% year over year as well.

More important was the booming backlog, which grew 96% year over year to $78 billion. Caterpillar is receiving orders from construction companies faster than it can fulfill them, giving it short-term business predictability and pricing power. This is why at one point Caterpillar's shares were up over 400% in the last five years.

Managing a cyclical market

The problem with a business like Caterpillar is cyclicality. Today is a booming time, with strong growth in demand, so it wants to increase its manufacturing capacity to meet it.

However, this can turn ugly if a downturn ever materializes. Construction booms almost always come with an eventual bust, and the AI infrastructure trade may be no different. This is why many stocks associated with AI infrastructure have fallen over the last few months: Investors worry that these boom times are nearing an end.

At one point this year, Caterpillar stock traded at a price-to-earnings ratio (P/E) of over 50, which is significantly higher than at any point in its history. This meant that a lot of the AI benefits to its business were priced in, and perhaps even more.

Analyzing Burry's trade -- what should investors do now?

Burry bet against Caterpillar shares using put options, which are similar to shorting but with a specific expiration date. As Caterpillar has fallen around 50% from its highs, the value of these option contracts has risen substantially.

Investors like Burry rightly saw that Caterpillar was being valued as if the boom in AI demand for its construction products and services would be permanent. It turns out Wall Street is now worried it will be temporary, with profits coming back down to earth.

Does that mean investors can now buy Caterpillar stock? Or is it set to fall further?

Right now, Caterpillar has a P/E ratio of 23, which is much more reasonable than its previous peak of 50. At the same time, it should still see solid earnings growth in the quarters ahead, driven by this booming backlog and price increases it can implement due to the construction equipment supply shortage.

That still does not mean one should run out and buy up a bunch of Caterpillar shares. Smart investors buy for the long term, not the next few quarters. Operating in a highly cyclical industry, Caterpillar is a difficult stock to own. There are much better ones you can buy for your portfolio to hold for a decade.

Missed Nvidia in 2009? This Rare Signal Is Flashing Again

In 2009, a "Double Down" signal flashed for a little-known chipmaker called Nvidia. If you’d invested $5,000 then, you’d be sitting on $2,116,882 today.*

Now, for the first time in years, that same "Total Conviction" signal is flashing for a company 1/100th the size of Nvidia. It’s a key player in the $1.8 trillion space race, and with the stock recently sitting 20% off its highs, the window to get in early is closing fast.

Continue »

*Stock Advisor returns as of November 16, 2026.

Brett Schafer has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Caterpillar. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Disclaimer: For information purposes only. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
placeholder
Bitcoin Plunges 13% in a Week as Market Retreats to $60,000 LevelBitcoin plunged 13% over the past seven days as bullish defense lines crumbled in succession, officially kicking off the battle to defend the $60,000 mark.On November 16, following a viol
Author  TradingKey
11 hours ago
Bitcoin plunged 13% over the past seven days as bullish defense lines crumbled in succession, officially kicking off the battle to defend the $60,000 mark.On November 16, following a viol
placeholder
Silver Price Falls Below $50 to Hit Near One-Year Low: Why Is Silver Falling? As of the Asian session on Monday (November 16), silver prices (XAGUSD) extended their recent decline, falling for the third consecutive trading day and dropping nearly 3% intraday to tra
Author  TradingKey
13 hours ago
As of the Asian session on Monday (November 16), silver prices (XAGUSD) extended their recent decline, falling for the third consecutive trading day and dropping nearly 3% intraday to tra
placeholder
Silver Price Forecast: XAG/USD hits yearly lows below $47.50 amid hawkish Fed sentimentSilver price (XAG/USD) extends its losses for the third successive day, trading around $47.50 per troy ounce during Asian hours on Monday. Silver prices fell to a yearly low of $47.34, pressured by a strengthening US Dollar (USD) and elevated Treasury yields.
Author  FXStreet
16 hours ago
Silver price (XAG/USD) extends its losses for the third successive day, trading around $47.50 per troy ounce during Asian hours on Monday. Silver prices fell to a yearly low of $47.34, pressured by a strengthening US Dollar (USD) and elevated Treasury yields.
placeholder
Weekly Report: DXY 103.41, 10-year 5.15%, AUD carry 3bp — three FX regimes flipped in one weekThe dollar index rose 1.09% to 103.41, a 19-month high, while the US 10-year closed at 5.154% and the Australia-US two-year spread collapsed to about 3 basis points from 36. EURUSD fell 1.59% to 1.1024, USDJPY rose 1.51% to 159.78 and AUDUSD fell 1.79% to 0.6764, a 10-month low. Three FX regimes — the broad dollar, the US rate level and the Australian carry premium — flipped in the same week. This report marks the thresholds, ranks which one can flip back first, and lists the week's calendar.
Author  Irene Q.
18 hours ago
The dollar index rose 1.09% to 103.41, a 19-month high, while the US 10-year closed at 5.154% and the Australia-US two-year spread collapsed to about 3 basis points from 36. EURUSD fell 1.59% to 1.1024, USDJPY rose 1.51% to 159.78 and AUDUSD fell 1.79% to 0.6764, a 10-month low. Three FX regimes — the broad dollar, the US rate level and the Australian carry premium — flipped in the same week. This report marks the thresholds, ranks which one can flip back first, and lists the week's calendar.
placeholder
Weekly Report: Gold's $4,000 reclaim and Brent's $100 break were right calls — the silver call was wrongLast week this report said gold's $4,000 reclaim was not the trend and that Brent's supply premium was over. Gold fell 4.7% to $3,884.69 and Brent fell 2.52% to $95.84, so both were right. The call that missed was silver: we read a gold-silver ratio of 78.7 as silver being cheap, and the ratio instead broke above 80 to 81.1 as silver fell 5.35%. This report grades the three calls, explains the miss, and sets this week's scorecard around 3,852 gold, 93.73 Brent and 6.00 copper.
Author  Irene Q.
18 hours ago
Last week this report said gold's $4,000 reclaim was not the trend and that Brent's supply premium was over. Gold fell 4.7% to $3,884.69 and Brent fell 2.52% to $95.84, so both were right. The call that missed was silver: we read a gold-silver ratio of 78.7 as silver being cheap, and the ratio instead broke above 80 to 81.1 as silver fell 5.35%. This report grades the three calls, explains the miss, and sets this week's scorecard around 3,852 gold, 93.73 Brent and 6.00 copper.
goTop
quote