Solana NFT platform Metaplex faces legal warning over plan to seize unclaimed SOL

Source Cryptopolitan

Metaplex, an NFT platform built on Solana, faces legal threats after it announced an attempt to sweep SOL tokens that have not been claimed into its DAO treasury. Burwick Law, a legal firm specializing in cryptocurrency issues, released an open letter on April 22 protesting the action and demanding that it be reversed before April 25.

Recently, Metaplex launched a resize optimization for Token Metadata (TM) NFTs that allows the holders to get a small refund of SOL by April 25. The optimization arises from a technical change that shrinks the space the NFTs occupy in the Solana protocol. However, despite such adoption, over 54,000 SOLs worth more than $6.5M are believed to still be unclaimed, according to data found on Metaplex’s website.

The protocol previously explained that the remaining SOL will be sent to the DAO treasury once the deadline is up, but the direction for its utilization is uncertain. These possibilities range from airdrops, grants, or other form of community contribution. However, this lack of user control has raised concerns within the public domain.

“Unjust enrichment” claims could follow, lawyers say

According to Burwick Law, Metaplex’s broad strategy is legally risky and might result in unjust enrichment and legal action under consumer protection laws. In an open letter published on April 22, the firm stated that many NFT holders were never properly informed of the resizing procedure or the risks of failing to meet the deadline.

“Many minters never received clear notice that these lamports could be swept, let alone diverted to a treasury they do not control,” Burwick stated. The firm noted that the platform decision erodes decentralization as it points to ‘‘Code is law’’ is only valid provided the code is understood and unchangeable. If a protocol can rewrite yesterday’s deal tomorrow, then the idea of decentralized perma­nence is more like an empty sound.”

Burwick recommends refund with DAO bounty

Burwick additionally urged Metaplex to halt its execution and provide direct refunds to current holders of NFTs. It included a 90/10 plan where 90% of the remaining SOL unclaimed would be redistributed to users while 10% would be set aside to pay for the running of the DAO.

The law firm framed the compromise as a middle ground protecting user rights, ensuring DAO funding, and averting legal disputes. Burwick reports that other DeFi projects have taken similar measures to address refunds on rents without seeking legal action.

“The ball is in the DAO’s court,” Burwick wrote. “Let’s show the world that Web3 corrects its own course and lives up to its founding principles of transparency, immutability, and fair dealing.”

The letter also reflects the discontent of many NFT collectors, including Burwick, who feel that the organization could be a medium for misusing the funds raised.  

Burwick has several cases of representing clients who invested in tokens but whose tokens were mismanaged. Further, its current legal action filed against the LIBRA token team for alleged insider trading is its way of standing firm in investor protection within the digital asset market. As reported by Cryptopolitan, the law firm claimed that Kelsier, KIP, Meteora, and others conspired to conduct an unfair token issuance of LIBRA.

In February, Burwick sent a cease and desist letter to Pump.fun stating that the latter is using their logos and names of the tokens by offering them on the platform. The letter called for the “immediate removal” of tokens such as Dog Shit Going No Where (DOGSHIT2) because the firms claimed that they were being “impersonated” by the tokens through the illicit use of intellectual property.

Cryptopolitan Academy: Tired of market swings? Learn how DeFi can help you build steady passive income. Register Now

Disclaimer: For information purposes only. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
placeholder
【Daily Brief】10-year Treasury yield briefly tops 5%, S&P 500 slips to 7,602 and the dollar firms at 99.3 as the Fed's decision eve beginsThe 10-year Treasury yield touched 5.014% on Monday — its first print above 5% since October 2023 — while the S&P 500 closed 0.48% lower at 7,619.98 and the dollar index firmed to 99.3. Here is the full market wrap ahead of Wednesday's FOMC decision, the dot plot and the August retail sales report, plus today's CLARITY Act Senate vote.
Author  Irene Q.
Sep 15, Tue
The 10-year Treasury yield touched 5.014% on Monday — its first print above 5% since October 2023 — while the S&P 500 closed 0.48% lower at 7,619.98 and the dollar index firmed to 99.3. Here is the full market wrap ahead of Wednesday's FOMC decision, the dot plot and the August retail sales report, plus today's CLARITY Act Senate vote.
placeholder
October hike odds climb toward 60% as Goldman and BofA both flip — what Warsh's "dose of accommodation" really changedRate futures now price roughly 55% to 62% for a 25bp hike at the October 27-28 FOMC, up from about 30% before Chair Warsh's post-meeting framing that the Fed is merely "removing some accommodation." Goldman Sachs has added an October hike to its forecast and Bank of America now sees moves in both October and December. Here is the repricing, the language behind it, and the two data points that decide it.
Author  Irene Q.
Sep 23, Wed
Rate futures now price roughly 55% to 62% for a 25bp hike at the October 27-28 FOMC, up from about 30% before Chair Warsh's post-meeting framing that the Fed is merely "removing some accommodation." Goldman Sachs has added an October hike to its forecast and Bank of America now sees moves in both October and December. Here is the repricing, the language behind it, and the two data points that decide it.
placeholder
Four jobs reports in five days: what JOLTS, ADP, claims and the September payrolls mean for the October Fed decisionThe US labour market faces its densest data week of the month. JOLTS job openings land Tuesday (7.2 million expected), ADP on Wednesday (70,000 expected), initial claims on Thursday and the September non-farm payrolls on Friday (100,000 expected, down from 162,000). Markets price a 64%-70% chance of another quarter-point Fed hike on October 28. The dollar index sits at 100.77 and the S&P 500 at 7,729.8.
Author  Mitrade
Sep 28, Mon
The US labour market faces its densest data week of the month. JOLTS job openings land Tuesday (7.2 million expected), ADP on Wednesday (70,000 expected), initial claims on Thursday and the September non-farm payrolls on Friday (100,000 expected, down from 162,000). Markets price a 64%-70% chance of another quarter-point Fed hike on October 28. The dollar index sits at 100.77 and the S&P 500 at 7,729.8.
placeholder
Nvidia's $150 billion buyback landed — and the AI sector fell anyway. That's the signal worth tradingNvidia closed up 1.68% at $228.86 on 28 September after announcing a $150 billion share repurchase authorisation, the largest single corporate buyback on record, while the rest of the AI complex sold off: AMD -3.6%, Micron -2.6%, Meta -4.8% and the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index -1.61%. The divergence is not noise. Capital is rotating toward cash-flow certainty, not abandoning the AI theme. With Micron reporting after the close on 30 September, here is what the split means.
Author  Irene Q.
19 hours ago
Nvidia closed up 1.68% at $228.86 on 28 September after announcing a $150 billion share repurchase authorisation, the largest single corporate buyback on record, while the rest of the AI complex sold off: AMD -3.6%, Micron -2.6%, Meta -4.8% and the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index -1.61%. The divergence is not noise. Capital is rotating toward cash-flow certainty, not abandoning the AI theme. With Micron reporting after the close on 30 September, here is what the split means.
placeholder
The 30-year Treasury just hit a 22-year high — and the bond market is not pricing the Fed, it is pricing the deficitThe 30-year Treasury yield closed at 5.56% on 28 September, the highest since June 2004, while the 10-year reached 5.24% and the 20-year 5.60%. The curve has steepened roughly 30bp in eight sessions even as October hike odds sit at 70.3%. That gap is the story: the long end is repricing fiscal and inflation risk, not policy. With PCE on Wednesday and payrolls on Friday, here is what the long end is really saying.
Author  Irene Q.
18 hours ago
The 30-year Treasury yield closed at 5.56% on 28 September, the highest since June 2004, while the 10-year reached 5.24% and the 20-year 5.60%. The curve has steepened roughly 30bp in eight sessions even as October hike odds sit at 70.3%. That gap is the story: the long end is repricing fiscal and inflation risk, not policy. With PCE on Wednesday and payrolls on Friday, here is what the long end is really saying.
goTop
quote