Target vs. Walmart: What's the Better Dividend Stock to Buy and Hold?

The Motley Fool
Updated
Mitrade
coverImg
Source: DepositPhotos

Target (NYSE: TGT) and Walmart (NYSE: WMT) are top retail stocks that can give investors a good way to invest in the economy's long-term growth. They can also generate a lot of dividend income for your portfolio. This year, Walmart has been the clear winner in terms of sheer stock performance, generating year-to-date returns of around 75% versus a 9% decline for Target, at the time of this writing.


But for dividend investors, the priorities will be a bit different. While Target is vastly underperforming Walmart today, that may not necessarily be the case for the next 10-plus years, which is how long dividend investors may be thinking about holding on to an investment.


If your priority is a good dividend stock and you're looking at holding on to an investment for the long haul, I'll look at which of these stocks may be the better option for you right now.


Target offers a much higher payout today


When a dividend stock surges the way Walmart has, that shrinks its yield as it means investors will need to pay more money to collect the same dividend. Walmart's yield is right around 1% today, which is below the S&P 500 average of approximately 1.2%. If, however, the stock was trading at the levels it was at to start the year, its yield would be approximately 1.6%.Target, by comparison, yields 3.4%.


To collect a $1,000 dividend from Walmart over the course of a full year, you would need to invest around $100,000 given its fairly low yield. But with a much higher payout, you would need to invest less than $30,000 into Target stock to collect the same level of dividend income.


Both companies have been growing their dividend payments


For dividend investors, a key criteria to consider when evaluating stocks is also the likelihood that they will increase their dividend income in the future, to not just grow the cash flow but to help offset the effects of inflation.


Earlier this year, Target raised its dividend by just under 2%, which marked the 53rd consecutive year which it boosted its dividend. As a Dividend King, Target has established itself as a top dividend growth stock to buy and hold over the years. Walmart is also part of that club, and in February it increased its quarterly dividend by 9%. The big-box retailer has now raised its dividend for 51 straight years.


While the recent increase was larger for Walmart, it's Target which has made the more generous raises over the past decade, doubling its dividend over that time frame.


TGT Dividend Chart

TGT Dividend data by YCharts


Both dividends look safe and sustainable


Another important metric to consider is the payout ratio, which tells investors just how much of its earnings a company is paying out in dividends. Both of these stocks have payout ratios of less than 50%, with Walmart having a bit more of a buffer than its rival.


TGT Payout Ratio Chart

TGT Payout Ratio data by YCharts


A lower payout ratio doesn't mean that Walmart's future increases will be larger than Target's. The company may prefer to keep its payout ratio low and manageable, as distributing too much of earnings out to shareholders could drain its cash, which it may prefer to use on its growth strategies, especially as it continues to battle Amazon.


What the above chart does tell investors, however, is that both dividend payments from Target and Walmart are currently safe and manageable, and there is room for more rate hikes in the future.


Dividend investors may want to consider Target


Target has been struggling this year due to underwhelming demand for discretionary products. But as economic conditions improve in the long run, the tide could change. And with Walmart also trading at a far higher valuation (34 times next year's estimated earnings versus a multiple of 13 for Target), it may be more susceptible to a correction, making Target the better value option for investors.


If you're investing for the long haul and dividend income is important to you, then buying shares of Target could be the better move to make today than jumping onto Walmart's already hot bandwagon.

* The content presented above, whether from a third party or not, is considered as general advice only.  This article should not be construed as containing investment advice, investment recommendations, an offer of or solicitation for any transactions in financial instruments.

goTop
quote
Do you find this article useful?
Related Articles
placeholder
Tesla’s European Sales Plummet in April, Marking Four Months of DeclineEuropeans are still buying more electric cars due to strict emissions regulations and lower prices. However, Tesla is facing competition from Chinese rivals and changes in consumer sentiment.
Author  Insights
15 hours ago
Europeans are still buying more electric cars due to strict emissions regulations and lower prices. However, Tesla is facing competition from Chinese rivals and changes in consumer sentiment.
placeholder
Australia hands Tesla lifeline with May sales surge, struggles persist elsewhereAustralia just gave Tesla something it hasn’t had in a while—relief. The company said on Tuesday that it sold 3,897 electric vehicles in Australia in May 2025, its best monthly performance in nearly a year, according to data reported by CNBC.
Author  Cryptopolitan
Yesterday 10: 28
Australia just gave Tesla something it hasn’t had in a while—relief. The company said on Tuesday that it sold 3,897 electric vehicles in Australia in May 2025, its best monthly performance in nearly a year, according to data reported by CNBC.
placeholder
Toyota Motor Corporation stock plunge after $33 billion acquisitionOn Wednesday, Toyota Motor Corporation shares dropped 13% after news of a buyout deal.
Author  Cryptopolitan
Yesterday 08: 58
On Wednesday, Toyota Motor Corporation shares dropped 13% after news of a buyout deal.
placeholder
NVIDIA regains title of world's most valuable company! Stock rises 2.8%, AI leader makes triumphant returnOn Tuesday, U.S. East Coast time, NVIDIA (NVIDIA.US) shares rose 2.8% to close at $141.22, giving the company a market capitalization of $3.45 trillion and surpassing Microsoft to reclaim the top spot among the world's largest listed companies.
Author  TradingKey
Yesterday 08: 53
On Tuesday, U.S. East Coast time, NVIDIA (NVIDIA.US) shares rose 2.8% to close at $141.22, giving the company a market capitalization of $3.45 trillion and surpassing Microsoft to reclaim the top spot among the world's largest listed companies.
placeholder
Kospi Index Rises Over 2% After Lee Jae-Myung Won South Korea PresidencyThe candidate from South Korea's Democratic Party, Lee Jae-myung, has officially been confirmed as the winner of the 21st South Korean presidential election and will assume office immediately.
Author  TradingKey
Yesterday 02: 33
The candidate from South Korea's Democratic Party, Lee Jae-myung, has officially been confirmed as the winner of the 21st South Korean presidential election and will assume office immediately.