Is Bitcoin the new Gold? The strategic implication of a U.S. reserve

Source Cryptopolitan

The United States government is assessing the creation of a strategic Bitcoin reserve following President Donald Trump’s instruction. This initiative could open a new chapter in Bitcoin’s involvement in national economic planning and guarantee a heated discussion about its advantages and disadvantages.

The directive, issued Thursday, requires the group to submit a report on or before July with recommendations on how federal law enforcement assets might be used to create a Bitcoin reserve. The model resembles the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve, but it prompts questions on the possibility and consequences of considering Bitcoin as a national reserve asset.

The idea of a Bitcoin reserve has recently gained traction in the crypto industry. This has largely been fueled by prominent crypto supporters and pro-crypto lawmakers like Senator Cynthia Lummis. Her “Bitcoin Act of 2024” describes a plan to create a Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, with a plan to buy between 100,000 and 1,000,000 BTC over five years. 

These assets would be stored in multiple decentralized cold wallets in different locations in the United States. Currently, the U.S. government possesses about 200,000 Bitcoin worth $21 billion.

Judicial implications of managing Bitcoin reserves

The adoption of Bitcoin as part of national assets poses certain legal issues. Most of the legal frameworks governing fiat currencies and commodities do not capture Bitcoin’s decentralized and cross-border nature. This is because new legislation may have to be formulated to provide the legal context for Bitcoin’s definition and the extent of its utility as a reserve currency.

There are also issues of conflict of ownership, security issues, and liability issues in case of hacking or fraud. Centralization, often connected to traditional reserves, may be hard to mimic for Bitcoin and remain true to its decentralization model.

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has also dismissed the idea that the central bank owns Bitcoin. He further stated that the Federal Reserve Act does not permit that. Also, since Bitcoin has characteristics that do not easily fall under legal classifications, it is difficult to control. Policymakers must decide whether to include Bitcoin in the present asset class, which includes foreign exchange or instruments of credit.

For example, the Exchange Stabilization Fund (ESF) could be used to purchase Bitcoin through credit. However, this approach would require a legal check on the provisions of the statutes to avoid any violation. 

Globally, Bitcoin reserves may be a subject of regulation under cross-border trade and investment laws and economic treaties. Regulatory alignment between countries will be necessary to avoid conflicts, such as taxation, anti-money laundering protocols, and digital asset custody laws.

Advocates vs. skeptics

The proposal has attracted considerable controversy among policymakers, financial gurus, and market actors. According to its supporters, Bitcoin’s limited supply and the fact that it is not controlled by any single entity mean it can act as inflation insurance and a useful asset for central banks.

Michael Saylor, the executive chairman of MicroStrategy, has been one of the most prominent advocates for Bitcoin, explaining that it is a better reserve asset. Since Saylor took over the helm at MicroStrategy, the company has purchased more than 461,000 BTC. BlackRock CEO Larry Fink has also endorsed Bitcoin, saying that it is “digital gold” and that its price may rise to $700,000.

However, critics highlight its risks. These include its notorious volatility, lack of intrinsic use, and speculative nature, which make it a divisive choice for a government reserve. Galileo FX CEO David Materazzi cautioned against gambling taxpayer money on a highly volatile speculative asset, as governments should stand for stability rather than profit.

Others, like Alexandr Sharilov from CoinDataFlow, pointed out that such volatility may spill over to other economies and cause a “digital arms race” if poorly managed. “If the price of Bitcoin falls, it could trigger a digital arms race and disrupt the global economy.”

How many countries are in?

However, the U.S. is not the only country that has an interest in using Bitcoin in its national reserves. Switzerland is considering including Bitcoin in its reserves besides gold.

El Salvador has already preceded other countries by making Bitcoin legal tender in 2021. However, not all countries are making Bitcoin a national reserve. In Japan, Prime Minister Ishiba Shigeru affirmed that Bitcoin cannot be considered a foreign exchange asset. Japan’s foreign exchange reserves, he emphasized, are for handling currency-based assets and bonds, which are a far cry from the volatility of Bitcoin.

The uncertainty of the government’s desire to acquire more Bitcoin in the future is still a mystery. While Trump’s order is sparse on this front, it has sparked renewed interest in discussing the potential of Bitcoin within national reserve assets.

Disclaimer: For information purposes only. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
placeholder
Japanese Yen dives to one-week low against USD amid rising trade tensionsThe Japanese Yen (JPY) drifts lower for the third straight day on Wednesday and slides to a one-week low against its American counterpart during the Asian session.
Author  FXStreet
Yesterday 02: 41
The Japanese Yen (JPY) drifts lower for the third straight day on Wednesday and slides to a one-week low against its American counterpart during the Asian session.
placeholder
Best Stock to Buy Right Now: Amazon vs AppleAmazon (NASDAQ: AMZN) and Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL) have become among the world's most recognized companies. They've also become very valuable, with the former's market cap exceeding $2
Author  The Motley Fool
Yesterday 10: 02
Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN) and Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL) have become among the world's most recognized companies. They've also become very valuable, with the former's market cap exceeding $2
placeholder
Goldman Sachs’ Bitcoin ETF Bet Soars To $1.5 BillionGoldman Sachs has ramped up its spot Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) holdings to over $1.5 billion, underscoring its deepening commitment to cryptocurrencies in the final quarter of 2024. The latest 13F filing with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) shows a notable expansion in both BTC and Ethereum-related positions, reflecting growing institutional confidence in […]
Author  Bitcoinist
10 hours ago
Goldman Sachs has ramped up its spot Bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) holdings to over $1.5 billion, underscoring its deepening commitment to cryptocurrencies in the final quarter of 2024. The latest 13F filing with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) shows a notable expansion in both BTC and Ethereum-related positions, reflecting growing institutional confidence in […]
placeholder
Dogecoin Price Breakout From Robust Structure Zone Signals Sharp 50% Rise Above $0.33Technical analysis shows that Dogecoin is looking to break out from a key structure zone near $0.26, which could cause a change in market momentum. This technical outlook comes amidst a bearish week for DOGE, which has seen it breaking below support levels and erasing its gains throughout January. According to a technical analysis of […]
Author  Bitcoinist
10 hours ago
Technical analysis shows that Dogecoin is looking to break out from a key structure zone near $0.26, which could cause a change in market momentum. This technical outlook comes amidst a bearish week for DOGE, which has seen it breaking below support levels and erasing its gains throughout January. According to a technical analysis of […]
placeholder
XRP Price Finds Stability—Can It Turn Higher from Here?XRP price is moving higher from the $2.320 support zone. The price must clear the $2.50 and $2.52 levels to start a fresh increase in the near term. XRP price started a decent upward move from the
Author  NewsBTC
6 hours ago
XRP price is moving higher from the $2.320 support zone. The price must clear the $2.50 and $2.52 levels to start a fresh increase in the near term. XRP price started a decent upward move from the
goTop
quote