Insiders Are Selling Refiners and Skipping Banks. What Should Investors Do?

Mitrade Team
coverImg
Source: DepositPhotos

Executives at refiners Par Pacific and PBF Energy are selling shares after gains of 149% and 210% this year. Meanwhile, the number of financial executives buying company stock fell to a near 23-year low.

Insider trades are public, yet they make a blunt guide. Ben Silverman, head of research at insider-data firm VerityData, says they suit single companies better than whole sectors.

Why Is Insider Selling Hitting Refiners at Record Highs?

VerityData’s chart compares how many insiders sell against how many buy, with 1.0 marking a sector’s long-run norm. Energy ranks second, at about 1.4 times its long-run average, against 1.2 for the overall market.

Financials show the highest insider seller-to-buyer ratio of any sector in the third quarter. Financials show the highest insider seller-to-buyer ratio of any sector in the third quarter. Source: VerityData

Par Pacific and PBF, both smaller oil refiners, trade at all-time highs, according to Wall Street Journal columnist Spencer Jakab. PBF’s adjusted second-quarter earnings swung to $6.22 per share from a year-earlier loss.

Diesel’s effective refinery price passed $200 per barrel last week, Jakab writes. The Group of Seven nations then agreed to release 100 million barrels from emergency stocks, including diesel.

Jakab doubts that diesel pricing can hold. He suggests executives with decades in refining see the limits better than investors do.

However, Jakab adds that insiders can be wrong about how investors feel toward their own industry.

Should Thin Insider Buying at Financials Worry Investors?

Financials top the chart at roughly 2.1 times their long-run average. Selling did not rise, VerityData found, so thinner buying drove the reading.

Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and JPMorgan Chase report next week with Treasury yields above 5%. Per-share profits at each now stand near four times their level a decade ago, Jakab notes.

Still, Jakab flags strain in private credit (lending outside banks), stressed consumers and record borrowing by artificial intelligence (AI) firms.

In contrast, consumer staples sit lowest, at about half their long-run average. Insiders at Altria, Tyson Foods and energy drink maker Celsius Holdings recently bought shares.

Investors can read SEC Form 4 filings, which log insider trades publicly, such as the Nvidia insider selling filing. With the Nasdaq at a record, those tallies may show how far executives trust current valuations.

Disclaimer: The content presented above, whether from a third party or not, is considered as general advice only. CFD trading involves significant risk of loss. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This article serves informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Consider your risk tolerance before trading.

goTop
quote
Related Articles
placeholder
Little-Known CoreWeave CEO Line Helps Fuel 15% CRWV Stock RallyOne sentence helped lift CoreWeave (CRWV) stock 15.6% to $56.33 in premarket trading Wednesday. CEO Michael Intrator told investors the AI cloud company would stop borrowing where lenders charge it mo
Author  Beincrypto
22 hours ago
One sentence helped lift CoreWeave (CRWV) stock 15.6% to $56.33 in premarket trading Wednesday. CEO Michael Intrator told investors the AI cloud company would stop borrowing where lenders charge it mo
placeholder
AI Selloff Sends Berkshire to Its Biggest S&P 500 Lead Since 2010: Can It Last?A selloff in artificial intelligence (AI) stocks has handed Berkshire Hathaway its biggest lead over the S&P 500 since 2010. Berkshire beat the index by 19.2 percentage points in the month to Thursday
Author  Beincrypto
22 hours ago
A selloff in artificial intelligence (AI) stocks has handed Berkshire Hathaway its biggest lead over the S&P 500 since 2010. Berkshire beat the index by 19.2 percentage points in the month to Thursday
placeholder
Microsoft Beats Nvidia for the First Time Since 2025: So Why Is MSFT Stock Falling?Microsoft beat Nvidia in market value on Tuesday to become the world’s second-most valuable company, the first time since June 2025. By midday, Microsoft’s own stock had dropped more than 3%, and the
Author  Beincrypto
Nov 11, Wed
Microsoft beat Nvidia in market value on Tuesday to become the world’s second-most valuable company, the first time since June 2025. By midday, Microsoft’s own stock had dropped more than 3%, and the
placeholder
Analysts Split on How to Trade Nvidia After Jensen Huang Spy ScandalNvidia (NVDA) fell 5.53% on Tuesday, extending a selloff tied to CEO Jensen Huang’s affair with an alleged Chinese spy. CNBC’s Investment Committee split on how to trade Nvidia, weighing a buying oppo
Author  Beincrypto
Nov 11, Wed
Nvidia (NVDA) fell 5.53% on Tuesday, extending a selloff tied to CEO Jensen Huang’s affair with an alleged Chinese spy. CNBC’s Investment Committee split on how to trade Nvidia, weighing a buying oppo
placeholder
Wall Street's Panic Gauge Just Broke a 13-Year Record. Goldman Says History Favors a ReboundGoldman Sachs’ Vol Panic Index posted its biggest two-day swing on record last week, beating an April 2013 high. The gauge collapsed during the midterm relief rally, then jumped to 9.57 out of 10 a da
Author  Beincrypto
Nov 11, Wed
Goldman Sachs’ Vol Panic Index posted its biggest two-day swing on record last week, beating an April 2013 high. The gauge collapsed during the midterm relief rally, then jumped to 9.57 out of 10 a da
Live Quotes
Name / SymbolChart% Change / Price
US500
US500
0.00%0.00

US Stocks Related Articles

  • CoreWeave just reignited the AI trade — can the NAS100 rally survive the spending backlash?
  • The Fed has paused, but rates are still high — which stocks are most exposed?
  • Meta is raising up to $97.5 billion for AI — will dilution become the next risk for the stock?
  • How to Buy AMD Stock in Australia in 2026: A Beginner’s Guide
  • How to Buy SpaceX Stock in Australia: Best Brokers, Fees and Investment Options for 2026
  • How to Invest in SpaceX in Australia (2026): Stock Price, Q3 Earnings & Buying Guide

Click to view more