Silver has crashed 60% from its peak — is XAGUSD finally becoming the more interesting precious-metals trade?

Updated
Mitrade Team
coverImg
Source: DepositPhotos

Silver has fallen from above $120 an ounce in January to around $46–48, wiping out roughly 60% of its peak value and leaving XAGUSD near its lowest level in more than a year. Gold has also struggled, but the reasons behind the weakness are increasingly different.

XAUUSD is being squeezed by a 19-month-high US dollar, 10-year Treasury yields around 5.1% and expectations that the Federal Reserve will raise rates again in December. Silver faces all of those pressures too, but it also carries a second problem: industrial demand is weakening after record prices accelerated substitution in solar manufacturing and higher costs reduced jewellery and silverware consumption.

That gives traders two very different precious-metals setups. Gold remains the cleaner trade on rates, the dollar and safe-haven demand, while silver combines those monetary forces with an industrial cycle tied to solar panels, electronics, vehicles and Chinese manufacturing.

The scale of silver’s decline also raises the more interesting question. After such a deep correction, could XAGUSD now react more violently than gold if precious-metals sentiment turns, or does weakening industrial demand still leave silver with more downside risk?

InstrumentCurrent pressurePotential catalyst
XAGUSDWeaker industrial and jewellery demand, high ratesSofter Fed outlook, industrial recovery, renewed investment demand
XAUUSDHigh Treasury yields and strong US dollarLower yields, weaker dollar, safe-haven demand
BothDecember Fed hike expectationsFOMC minutes, inflation, jobs and dollar moves

Silver’s extraordinary rally has almost completely unwound

Silver traded above $121 an ounce during January’s precious-metals surge before collapsing back toward $50 and recently slipping below that level. The move has been much more violent than gold’s pullback because silver trades in a smaller market and responds simultaneously to investment demand and changes in industrial consumption.

Open a Silver Trading Account

      “Trade XAGUSD with an ASIC-regulated broker. Fast AUD funding via PayID. ”  

The rally itself had been supported by a powerful combination of tight supply, strong solar demand and investors looking for a higher-beta alternative to gold. Once prices reached extreme levels, some of those forces began working in reverse. Manufacturers accelerated efforts to reduce the amount of silver used in photovoltaic cells, consumers cut purchases of jewellery and silverware and investors became less willing to chase the metal at record prices.

Silver’s latest decline therefore reflects more than a broad sell-off in precious metals. Parts of the demand story that helped justify the January surge have genuinely weakened.

The market is still expected to record a sixth consecutive annual supply deficit in 2026, with demand exceeding supply by around 35 million ounces, so silver has not suddenly become abundant. The difficulty for XAGUSD is that a structural deficit can coexist with falling prices when investment demand weakens and users adapt to high costs.

Solar demand is no longer the automatic bullish story it once was

Industrial demand is forecast to fall about 3% this year to roughly 640 million ounces, even though consumption outside solar remains relatively resilient. Demand excluding photovoltaics is expected to rise around 4.5%, supported by vehicle electrification, charging infrastructure and uses such as brazing alloys and solders.

The pressure is concentrated heavily in solar. Installations have fallen short of previous expectations, particularly in China, while manufacturers have accelerated “thrifting,” reducing the amount of silver required in each photovoltaic cell. High silver prices also increase the incentive to substitute cheaper materials wherever technology permits.

This changes the way traders need to think about XAGUSD. Strong growth in renewable energy does not automatically translate into equally strong growth in silver demand if each new panel requires less metal.

Jewellery and silverware are weakening too, with demand forecast to fall by 22% and 17% respectively this year. High prices have encouraged consumers to buy smaller products or delay purchases, particularly in price-sensitive markets such as India.

Total silver demand is now expected to fall about 5% to 1.08 billion ounces in 2026. That is not a collapse, but it removes some of the fundamental momentum that helped carry silver to extraordinary highs earlier in the year.

Gold’s problem is less about demand and more about the price of money

Gold is facing a different set of pressures. Spot gold (XAUUSD) has hit its lowest level since October 2025; however, the ain problem is not a collapse in physical demand.

Open a Gold Trading Account

      “Trade XAUUSD with an ASIC-regulated broker. Fast AUD funding via PayID. ”  

The 10-year Treasury yield is holding around 5.1%, while the US dollar has reached its strongest level in roughly 19 months. Markets are also assigning a very high probability to another Federal Reserve rate increase in December after inflation remained hotter than expected.

Those conditions increase the opportunity cost of holding a non-yielding asset such as gold. Investors can earn more than 5% on longer-dated US government debt while holding an asset denominated in a strengthening dollar, making bullion less attractive unless safe-haven demand becomes strong enough to offset that disadvantage.

Central-bank buying still provides structural support, but it has not been enough to stop the recent decline. Gold therefore remains extremely sensitive to any shift in Fed expectations, Treasury yields or the dollar.

For XAUUSD traders, the near-term setup is relatively clear: softer US data or a more cautious Fed could pressure yields and support gold, while another hawkish repricing would keep the current headwind in place.

Silver has the same rates problem with an extra industrial layer

Silver does not escape any of the pressures affecting gold. It is also non-yielding, priced in dollars and vulnerable when Treasury yields rise.

The difference is that XAGUSD has to absorb those monetary pressures while also responding to industrial demand. That can make silver more volatile in both directions.

If the Fed outlook softens, silver could benefit from the same lower-yield and weaker-dollar forces that support gold while simultaneously attracting traders looking for a more aggressive precious-metals rebound. Silver’s smaller market can amplify those moves once investment flows return.

Weak Chinese manufacturing, slower solar demand or further substitution could produce the opposite effect. Gold can still attract defensive demand during periods of economic uncertainty, while silver may struggle if traders interpret the same slowdown as negative for industrial consumption.

That dual role is why XAGUSD can move much faster than XAUUSD without necessarily moving for exactly the same reasons.

The supply deficit still puts a floor under the bearish story

Silver demand may be falling, but supply has not responded with a major increase. Mine production is expected to remain broadly flat this year, while recycling is forecast to rise by around 6%.

The result is another annual deficit despite weaker consumption. Silver has now spent several years with demand exceeding newly available supply, leaving the market dependent on inventories accumulated in previous periods.

That limits how bearish the industrial-demand argument can become. Falling demand does not automatically create oversupply when mine production remains constrained.

For traders, the tension between weaker near-term consumption and persistent structural deficits could produce exactly the type of volatility that makes XAGUSD more active than gold.

A recovery in investment demand would encounter a market that is still fundamentally tight, while continued weakness in industrial consumption could keep sentiment depressed even without an outright surplus.

Could XAGUSD now outperform XAUUSD on a rebound?

Silver’s collapse has created a much larger reset in expectations than gold’s decline. XAGUSD has lost around 60% from its January high, while XAUUSD remains much closer to the extraordinary levels reached during its own rally.

That does not automatically make silver cheap, but it changes the risk-reward debate.

A softer Fed outlook could benefit both metals, yet silver has more room to respond if traders begin rebuilding speculative exposure. A weaker dollar, falling yields and signs that industrial demand is stabilising could create several bullish forces at once.

Gold would probably remain the cleaner reaction to a monetary-policy shift because its relationship with yields and the dollar is more direct. Silver could produce the larger percentage move if that monetary support arrives alongside better industrial sentiment.

The downside is equally important. If rates stay high and Chinese or solar demand weakens further, silver has fewer defensive characteristics to protect it than gold.

XAGUSD therefore offers the more volatile setup, while XAUUSD remains the cleaner macro trade.

What could move XAGUSD and XAUUSD next?

  • Fed minutes: A more hawkish tone would reinforce expectations for another rate hike and keep pressure on both metals.

  • December rate expectations: Any shift away from another increase could quickly reduce the yield headwind.

  • Treasury yields: A sustained fall from above 5% would improve the relative appeal of precious metals.

  • US dollar: Continued strength would weigh on both XAGUSD and XAUUSD, while a reversal could support a rebound.

  • Chinese industrial activity: Stronger manufacturing would be more important for silver because of its industrial exposure.

  • Solar demand: Changes in installations, silver loadings and substitution could reshape the longer-term XAGUSD outlook.

  • Safe-haven demand: Geopolitical or financial stress would generally provide more direct support to gold.

Trading XAGUSD and XAUUSD with Mitrade

Eligible Australian clients can use Mitrade CFDs to trade both silver and gold without owning the physical metals.

XAGUSD offers exposure to a more volatile combination of precious-metal sentiment and industrial demand, while XAUUSD is more directly linked to interest rates, the dollar and safe-haven flows. Traders can take long positions if they expect prices to rise or short positions if they expect further weakness.

That distinction can be useful in the current market because silver and gold are not simply interchangeable versions of the same trade. A softer Fed outlook may support both, while weaker industrial demand could leave XAGUSD underperforming even if gold begins to stabilise.

Stop-loss and take-profit orders can help define exit levels, while pending orders allow positions to open when selected prices are reached. Precious metals can move sharply around inflation data, Fed communications and geopolitical events, so leverage and position sizing remain important.

Mitrade is regulated in Australia by ASIC. Commodity CFDs are leveraged products, so both potential gains and losses can be magnified.

Start trading in three steps

1
Create and Verify Your Account
Sign up on Mitrade and complete identity verification.
Open a Mitrade Account
2
Deposit Funds
Fund your account using supported AUD payment methods, including Visa, Mastercard, PayID, and bank transfers.
3
Set a market view:
Choose XAGUSD or XAUUSD, then take a long or short position based on your outlook.
FAQ

1. Why has silver fallen more sharply than gold?

Silver is more volatile and has greater exposure to industrial demand. Weakness in solar, jewellery and silverware demand has added to the pressure from higher interest rates and a stronger dollar.

2. Is silver still in a supply deficit?

Yes. The global silver market is expected to record a sixth consecutive annual deficit in 2026, with demand exceeding supply despite the decline in industrial and consumer demand.

3. Could silver outperform gold if the Fed turns less hawkish?

It could. Both metals would likely benefit from lower yields and a weaker dollar, but silver’s smaller market and higher volatility can produce larger percentage moves. Weak industrial demand would remain an additional risk.

4. What is the main difference between trading XAGUSD and XAUUSD?

XAUUSD is more directly influenced by rates, the dollar and safe-haven demand. XAGUSD responds to those same factors but also carries significant exposure to industrial demand from solar, electronics, vehicles and manufacturing.

Disclaimer: The content presented above, whether from a third party or not, is considered as general advice only. CFD trading involves significant risk of loss. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This article serves informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Consider your risk tolerance before trading.

goTop
quote
Related Articles
placeholder
How To Buy Silver In Australia Online? 06 Best Place to Buy Silver in AustraliaWhere to buy silver online in Australia? We reveal the 06 top-rated platforms for low premiums, secure transactions & insured delivery. Learn how to purchase physical silver (coins/bars) or ETFs tax-efficiently (GST-free!). Find your trusted dealer now!
Author  Mitrade TeamInsights
Mar 02, Mon
Where to buy silver online in Australia? We reveal the 06 top-rated platforms for low premiums, secure transactions & insured delivery. Learn how to purchase physical silver (coins/bars) or ETFs tax-efficiently (GST-free!). Find your trusted dealer now!
placeholder
Silver Price Prediction 2026: Why It’s Harder to Call Than GoldThe silver price prediction for 2026 is shaped by industrial demand, Fed policy, and supply constraints. Discover what analysts are watching.
Author  Reddy Shiva ShankarInsights
Apr 29, Wed
The silver price prediction for 2026 is shaped by industrial demand, Fed policy, and supply constraints. Discover what analysts are watching.
placeholder
7 Best Place to Buy Silver in Australia (2026): Coins, Bullion & Online Dealers ComparedLooking for the best place to buy silver in Australia in 2026? This guide compares 7 trusted options, including online platforms, bullion dealers and silver coins, to help Australian investors choose safely and confidently.
Author  Mitrade TeamInsights
Aug 07, Fri
Looking for the best place to buy silver in Australia in 2026? This guide compares 7 trusted options, including online platforms, bullion dealers and silver coins, to help Australian investors choose safely and confidently.
placeholder
Silver Price Recovers From 2026 Low, but April Arrives With a 36% Downside ThreatSilver (XAG/USD) price has bounced roughly 18% from its 2026 low, currently trading above $72. The recovery followed a hidden bullish divergence that began forming in December. Additionally, the lates
Author  BeincryptoBeincrypto
Apr 01, Wed
Silver (XAG/USD) price has bounced roughly 18% from its 2026 low, currently trading above $72. The recovery followed a hidden bullish divergence that began forming in December. Additionally, the lates
placeholder
Silver Price Slides Toward $66: Can Bullish Positioning Avoid a Fresh 2026 Low?Silver price is showing clear signs of weakness even as market sentiment remains tilted to the bullish side. While options data suggests traders still expect upside, price structure and demand signals
Author  BeincryptoBeincrypto
Mar 20, Fri
Silver price is showing clear signs of weakness even as market sentiment remains tilted to the bullish side. While options data suggests traders still expect upside, price structure and demand signals
Real-time Quote