My Top 10 Stocks to Buy in 2025 Are Beating the Market by 8 Percentage Points. Should You Buy Them for 2026?

Every year, I choose 10 top stocks to buy, and I evaluate how they've done relative to the market at the end of the year. In the past, my list has done exceptionally well. As of Dec. 10, if you had invested $1,000 in each of these stocks at the beginning of the year, and $10,000 in the S&P 500, you'd have $12,754 with my list, versus $11,770 from an index fund. That's an 8-percentage-point beat with my list.

Data by YCharts.

Normally, I'd be pretty disappointed with these results; It's still market-beating performance, but not by much. However, it's a great opportunity to reflect on what it means to be a long-term investor. This year, some of these stocks have fallen short. But over the past three years, they have beaten the market by a staggering percentage.

Data by YCharts.

If you had invested $1,000 in each of these stocks three years ago and $10,000 in the S&P 500, you'd have $33,385, versus $16,990 for the S&P 500, or be up 235% vs. 69%. Those are fantastic results.

Even the greatest stocks of all time have off years or off times. Stock prices on a short-term basis could be affected by so many things, like market sentiment or a disappointing quarterly result. Rather than seeing them as destructive to the whole investing thesis, you can see them as a buying opportunity.

In fact, the two stocks that are actually losing value in 2025 are two of my highest-conviction holdings; their businesses are both performing fabulously this year, and I have confidence they'll bounce back and beat the market over the long term.

I would also point out that the S&P 500 has been buoyed by artificial intelligence (AI) enthusiasm this year, which has propped up its returns, whereas my list is low on AI. That negatively impacts my list right now relative to the index, but over many decades, AI trends will end up as a short-term tailwind relative to total market returns.

Image source: Getty Images.

Let's take a quick look at each stock and what to think about it going into 2026:

1. Amazon

Amazon (NASDAQ: AMZN) is demonstrating strong growth in all of its businesses and has tremendous AI opportunities, but it's trailing the market this year. Investors seem to be concerned about competition and high AI spending. I wouldn't underestimate Amazon, and the sluggish price makes me even more confident about how much room it has to expand in 2026.

2. American Express

American Express (NYSE: AXP) is performing beautifully despite pressure on spending. It targets an affluent clientele that's less susceptible to inflationary issues, and it's well-positioned to manage through any rough times coming.

3. Carnival

Carnival (NYSE: CCL)(NYSE: CUK) performed phenomenally this year, but since some of its rebound is already priced into the stock, and investors are still worried about its debt, its stock was mediocre this year. It's still cheap, though, so if it makes strides in reducing the debt in 2026, the stock could outperform.

4. Dutch Bros

Dutch Bros (NYSE: BROS) had a fantastic 2025, but it's expensive, which might be why it's underperforming the market in 2025. That could lead to further low gains next year until the market is satisfied that not all of its growth is priced into the stock. Longer term, it looks like a no-brainer growth stock.

5. Lemonade

Lemonade (NYSE: LMND) has been the surprise winner for a few years. After the market seemed to have given up on it for a while, it's back in action. If it becomes profitable on the basis of adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA) this year as expected, the stock could keep climbing.

6. Global-e Online

Global-e Online (NASDAQ: GLBE) has had a fabulous 2025, but its stock has been the biggest loser on this list. That's because it specializes in cross-border trade and is expected to be heavily impacted by global trade wars. However, it continues to report high growth, and it reached net profitability earlier than expected. It also quickly developed solutions for its clients to manage through a challenging tariff environment. That should get a bug thumbs-up from investors, and this looks like an opportunity to buy on the dip.

7. MercadoLibre

MercadoLibre (NASDAQ: MELI) has been a reliable market beater for some time. It continues to enjoy healthy opportunities throughout its large and growing e-commerce and fintech businesses, and I expect it to keep rewarding investors for years.

8. Nu Holdings

Nu Holdings (NYSE: NU) has had a fantastic year, and it could get even better in 2026. The Brazilian digital bank is capturing market share and expanding into new regions, and it recently applied for a U.S. bank charter, giving it multiple growth avenues.

9. On Holdings

On Holdings (NYSE: ONON) is the only other stock on this list that's down this year, and for similar reasons to Global-e: It's an international company that relies on China for production. However, the company continues to report high growth, and it has massive long-term opportunities. 2026 could be a much better year if the tariff issue settles down.

10. SoFi

SoFi Technologies (NASDAQ: SOFI) has impressed investors this year as growth accelerates and it launches new, innovative products. The digital bank is catching on with young customers who will growth with the company, and lower interest rates are helping it grow. Expect further growth in 2026 and beyond.

American Express is an advertising partner of Motley Fool Money. Jennifer Saibil has positions in American Express, Dutch Bros, Global-E Online, Lemonade, MercadoLibre, Nu Holdings, On Holding, and SoFi Technologies. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Amazon, Global-E Online, Lemonade, MercadoLibre, and On Holding. The Motley Fool recommends Carnival Corp., Dutch Bros, and Nu Holdings. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.