[IN-DEPTH ANALYSIS] Zillow Unveiled: The Data-Driven Engine Behind U.S. Home Buying and Selling

Key Takeaways

• Market Leader: Zillow captures 43% of U.S. real estate web traffic with unmatched brand recognition and a network effect moat.
• Zestimate Edge: Its data-driven Zestimate delivers highly accurate home value estimates for listed properties, boosting user confidence.
• Valuation Target: Zillow’s 12-month target price is $64 to $87, based on a 23.5–30x EV/EBITDA multiple reflecting its strong growth and market position.

Source: TradingKey

TradingKey - Zillow Group is the top online real estate website in the United States. It’s where millions of people start when they want to buy, sell, or rent a home. Since it was founded in 2006, Zillow has changed the way people find homes by giving them easy access to home prices, listings, and helpful tools like the Zestimate, a popular estimate of a home’s value.

Tiger Global, led by star investor Chase Coleman, began accumulating Zillow shares in Q1 2025, signaling strong institutional confidence in Zillow’s growth prospects and digital platform leadership.

Source: TradingKey

Beyond Just Another Real Estate Website

You might wonder, "There are many real estate websites out there. What makes Zillow any different?" The answer is that Zillow is more than just a website. It’s the go-to place for most people looking for a home. It brings together listings, price estimates, financing options, and local agents in one easy-to-use place. This makes the whole process of finding or renting a home simpler and more transparent for millions of users every month.

But here's why Zillow truly stands out:

Unrivaled Brand Recognition and User Habit: For most Americans, Zillow is the first name that comes to mind when looking for a home online. It dominates the market, capturing about 43% of all real estate web traffic in the U.S according to SimilarWeb.

Source: SimilarWeb

This isn't just about advertising; it's about deeply ingrained user habits. When someone wants to check what a house down the street sells for or browse homes in a new city, Zillow is usually their first stop. This makes it the undisputed traffic leader in online real estate, attracting hundreds of millions of unique visitors every month. This massive, consistent audience is Zillow's primary, and perhaps most durable, competitive advantage.

Source: Zillow Earnings Reports, TradingKey

The Network Effect Moat: This is perhaps the most critical reason Zillow is special. Think of social media: the more people who use Facebook or LinkedIn, the more valuable it becomes for everyone else to be on it. Zillow operates on a similar principle, called a network effect.

• More Users = More Value for Professionals: Because Zillow attracts the largest audience of active and aspiring homebuyers, sellers, and renters, it becomes the most valuable place for real estate agents, mortgage lenders, and property managers to advertise and find clients. They have to be on Zillow because that's where the customers are.
• More Professionals = More Value for Users: As more agents and service providers join Zillow, they bring more listings, financing options, and services. This makes Zillow even more useful for consumers, which attracts even more users. This cycle creates a strong barrier for competitors—no matter how good their technology, they can’t easily replicate Zillow’s critical mass of users and professionals.

Data Scale and Sophistication: While other companies can develop algorithms, Zillow has a data advantage born from over two decades of unmatched scale. Every single search, click, save, and interaction from its hundreds of millions of users, combined with public property records and real-time listing data, feeds into Zillow's systems. This vast, proprietary dataset is far larger and richer than what a new entrant could quickly assemble. It allows Zillow to continuously refine its tools and predictions, like the Zestimate, with a level of accuracy and nuance that others struggle to match. It's not just an algorithm; it's an algorithm trained on the most extensive and dynamic dataset in residential real estate.

Integrated Ecosystem (“Housing Super App” Vision): Zillow is more than a search engine. It’s building a complete home-buying and renting experience. From finding a home to getting a mortgage, connecting with an agent, scheduling tours, and managing rentals, Zillow aims to simplify every step. This makes Zillow a “sticky” platform that users rely on throughout their housing journey, strengthening its competitive edge.

So, when we talk about Zillow, we're actually talking about a dominant digital platform built on powerful network effects, an unparalleled data advantage, and deep brand recognition that makes it a unique and enduring force in the real estate industry. This is why Zillow is special.

Zestimate

One of the most famous, and often debated, features that truly put Zillow on the map and cemented its user habit is Zestimate. It’s a sophisticated, proprietary algorithm that calculates an estimated market value for millions of homes, even those not actively for sale. Before Zillow, home values were mostly known through real estate agents’ opinions or costly appraisals, which were not always accessible or consistent for the average homeowner. While some digital valuation tools existed, Zillow was the first to offer a widely accessible, free, and frequently updated online home value estimate, bringing transparency and instant insight to millions of homeowners nationwide.

How the Zestimate Operates:

The Zestimate algorithm is built upon a vast, constantly updated dataset, using hundreds of distinct data points to form its valuations. These inputs include:

• Public property records: Official data like past sale prices, property tax assessments, and exact property boundaries.
• Real-time listing data: Zillow integrates current listing information from various Multiple Listing Service (MLS) databases, which are the authoritative sources for agent-listed properties.
• Recent comparable sales: A critical component, this involves analyzing the sale prices of similar homes in close proximity that have recently sold.
• User-provided information: Homeowners can update and add details about their properties directly on Zillow's platform, which helps improve the Zestimate's accuracy.
• Intrinsic home characteristics: Fundamental attributes like square footage, number of bedrooms and bathrooms, lot size, and precise geographical location are carefully included.
• Broader market dynamics: The algorithm also accounts for larger and smaller market trends, including regional housing supply and demand shifts, interest rate changes, and seasonal market variations.

The Zestimate algorithm is constantly being refined and improved. Newer versions even use computer vision to analyze photographs of homes. This allows the algorithm to understand qualitative features, such as the quality of interior finishes or a property's curb appeal, adding a deeper dimension beyond just numerical data.

How Accurate is the Zestimate?

• For homes currently listed for sale, the Zestimate is quite accurate, with a median error of about 1.94%. This means half of the time, the Zestimate is within 2% of the actual sale price.
• For off-market homes, the error is higher, around 7.06%, since less current data is available.

It's important for investors and consumers to recognize that while the Zestimate is an invaluable tool for initial insights, it is an estimation, not a formal appraisal. Its accuracy can be affected by external factors; for instance, a temporary, unusually high listing price set by an agent could briefly skew the Zestimate upwards for that property.

Regarding negotiations, the Zestimate serves as a powerful starting point for discussion, but it is not the final authority on price. Both buyers and sellers frequently refer to the Zestimate during negotiations. Ultimately, the final sale price depends on the negotiation between the buyer and seller, supported by current market conditions, professional appraisals, and comparative market analyses conducted by agents.

Zillow's Business Model: How This Digital Hub Generates Cash

Zillow isn't just a website; it's a powerful marketplace. It smartly uses its massive audience and rich data to connect people looking for homes with the professionals who help them. Unlike old-school real estate, Zillow thrives by being digital, which means it can grow much bigger, much faster.

Zillow's strategy is clever: it gives tons of free tools and information to everyday people. This brings in millions of users. Then, Zillow makes money by offering valuable services to the real estate professionals who want to reach these active homebuyers, sellers, and renters. Zillow acts like an online matchmaker, bringing everyone together and charging for better access and visibility.

Zillow pulls in its revenue from three core areas, each playing a crucial role in the overall home journey:

Source: Zillow Earnings Reports, TradingKey

Connecting Home Seekers with Agents (Residential Services): This is Zillow's largest moneymaker, primarily through its Premier Agent program. In Q1 2025, this segment generated $417 million in revenue, 70% of total revenue, marking a 6% increase year-over-year. Think of it as digital advertising for real estate professionals. 

• Why Agents Pay: Premier Agents get prime placement on listings and search results, high-quality leads from serious home shoppers, direct connections like instant tour requests, and tools to manage their clients and track performance.
• Pricing: Costs vary by local market competitiveness and agent goals. Agents typically pay monthly fees, but newer programs like Zillow Flex let agents pay referral fees only after a sale closes, reducing upfront risk.

Helping with Home Loans (Mortgage Services): Zillow Home Loans offers mortgage pre-approvals and financing options, helping buyers secure loans directly through Zillow’s platform. This keeps users engaged and streamlines the buying process. This segment saw rapid growth, producing $41 million in revenue during Q1 2025, 7% of total revenue, a 32% increase compared to the previous year, highlighting Zillow’s success in integrating financing solutions into its platform.

Supporting the Rental Market (Rental Services): Zillow’s rental marketplace serves landlords and property managers who pay to list and manage rental properties. With many people choosing to rent, this segment is expanding fast, generating $129 million in revenue in Q1 2025, 21% of total revenue, up 33% YoY, and adds diversification to Zillow’s revenue.

The iBuying Disaster: A Major Lesson Learned

Zillow’s iBuying venture, known as Zillow Offers, was a bold and ambitious move that ultimately proved costly and led to a major shift in the company’s strategy. Understanding this episode is essential for any investor assessing Zillow's current path.

Launched in 2018, Zillow Offers aimed to simplify home selling by having Zillow buy homes directly from sellers for cash, perform minor renovations, and quickly resell them. The promise was speed, certainty, and convenience for sellers. Zillow believed its advanced Zestimate algorithm, powered by vast market data, could accurately predict home prices, enabling the company to buy homes at a discount, improve them slightly, and sell for a profit.

In late 2021, Zillow abruptly ended iBuying, taking an $800 million loss and cutting 25% of its workforce. This decision shocked the market and caused Zillow’s stock price to plunge. Several critical factors contributed to the failure of the iBuying model:

Real Estate is Not a Simple Commodity: The fundamental flaw was treating individual homes like easily exchangeable products. Unlike financial instruments or manufactured goods, each residential property is unique, with countless specific characteristics, subjective conditions, and neighborhood appeals that even the most advanced algorithms struggle to fully quantify. While the Zestimate estimates value well, it couldn’t reliably predict short-term price movements in a fast-changing, illiquid market. Zillow ended up buying homes at peak prices just before markets cooled, causing losses when they couldn’t resell quickly at a profit according to ResiClub.

Source: ResiClub

High Capital Needs and Slow Sales: iBuying is inherently a capital-heavy business. It demanded enormous amounts of cash to acquire and maintain a vast inventory of physical properties. In sharp contrast to Zillow's asset-light advertising model, iBuying tied up billions of dollars in real estate inventory. When the housing market slowed, homes took longer to sell, increasing holding costs like taxes, insurance, and maintenance, which squeezed margins.

Operational Complexities Beyond Technology: Beyond just price prediction, iBuying involved intricate operational challenges, including physical property inspections, managing renovation contractors, dealing with supply chain issues, and executing swift sales. Zillow, primarily a technology company, lacked deep operational expertise in these areas at the scale required, leading to inefficiencies and increased costs.

The iBuying failure, though financially painful, served as an invaluable, albeit expensive, lesson. It forced Zillow to decisively pivot back to its core strengths: operating as a digital marketplace that connects participants. By exiting this capital-intensive and inherently risky venture, Zillow has emerged as a more focused entity. This strategic change signifies the company's full dedication to expanding its highly profitable advertising, mortgage, and rental businesses—segments that align far more closely with its strengths as a technology and data-driven enterprise.

Zillow's Financials: A Closer Look at Performance

Revenue Performance

Zillow reported $598 million in total revenue for Q1 2025, marking a robust 13% increase compared to the same quarter last year. This growth outpaced other competitors’ growth, highlighting Zillow’s expanding market presence.

Source: Zillow Earnings Reports, TradingKey

Profitability and Operational Efficiency

Zillow’s commitment to profitability is evident in its latest results. In Q1 2025, Zillow reported a GAAP net income of $8 million, marking a significant turnaround from a $23 million net loss in the same quarter last year. This translated to a net income margin of approximately 1%, reflecting modest but positive bottom-line profitability.

Zillow’s operating margin improved markedly to about -1.5% in Q1 2025, up from -7.4% a year earlier, showing meaningful progress in managing operating costs relative to revenue.

Source: Zillow Earnings Reports, TradingKey

Zillow’s operating margin stayed negative for so long, even before iBuying, because the company prioritized rapid growth, investing heavily in technology, marketing, and expanding its digital platform to build market share and reinforce its leadership position. These upfront costs kept expenses high relative to revenue, delaying sustained profitability. Despite this, Zillow maintained a strong cash position by raising significant capital through equity offerings by selling new shares to investors and by managing its balance sheet conservatively, avoiding excessive debt and keeping a substantial cash cushion to fund operations and strategic initiatives.

Source: Zillow Earnings Reports, TradingKey

Balance Sheet Strength and Liquidity

Zillow’s balance sheet remains robust, with $1.6 billion in cash and investments as of March 31, 2025. Despite a recent decline in cash, the company’s debt is also decreasing, keeping its debt-to-equity ratio low at 14%.

Source: Zillow Earnings Reports, TradingKey

• Mortgage Loans Held for Sale: loans that Zillow Home Loans originates for borrowers but temporarily keeps on its balance sheet before selling them to other investors, such as banks or government agencies. These loans are assets for Zillow, but the company usually doesn’t keep them long-term. Instead, Zillow makes money by quickly selling these loans, earning fees and gains from the sale rather than collecting interest over many years. Zillow’s increasing mortgage loans held for sale reflect growing mortgage business activity amid a cautiously recovering housing market. While this trend supports revenue growth, it also highlights the need for careful capital and risk management given market uncertainties in 2025.

Source: Zillow Earnings Reports, TradingKey

Zillow's financial results paint a picture of a company in a strong recovery and growth phase post iBuying strategic adjustments.

Valuation

For a high-growth, digital real estate platforms like Zillow, EV/EBITDA is the most relevant valuation metric. This ratio directly reflects operating profitability and allows for meaningful comparison with both digital peers and platform companies.

Note: Realtor.com is owned by News Corp (NWSA)

Source: StockAnalysis, TradingKey

Zillow’s EV/EBITDA multiple is 29.1x, which is higher than the peer median (23.5x) and average (24.7x), but still below DoorDash’s 41.2x. This premium is supported by Zillow’s strong EBITDA margin (22.8%), steady revenue growth, and its leading position in U.S. digital real estate. We use a 23.5–30x range for our valuation: the lower end (23.5x) anchors to the peer median for a conservative estimate, while the upper end (30x) matches Zillow’s current premium and rewards its market leadership and growth, without assuming extreme tech multiples. Applying it to projected Adjusted EBITDA of $600 million (base case) to $650 million (bull case) over the next 12 months and using TTM net cash and shares outstanding, a reasonable 12 month target price range for Zillow shares is $64–$87.

Risks to Consider

Zillow still faces several key risks, primarily tied to the broader U.S. housing market. Its business performance is sensitive to shifts in mortgage rates, housing inventory, and overall economic conditions. These factors can impact home sales and advertising demand on its platform. If mortgage rates stay high or rise further, affordability could decline and transaction volumes may drop, directly affecting Zillow’s core revenue streams. Additionally, a slowdown in economic growth or rising unemployment could weaken consumer confidence and reduce housing activity.

Get started